Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If a reader purchases through them, BioBoost Living may earn a small commission at no extra cost. We only recommend products we believe can genuinely help.
Renata, 53, had two browser tabs open at the kitchen table.
It was past ten. The dishwasher hummed. Her reading glasses kept sliding down her nose.
One tab said cool and minty. The other said warm and tingly.
Both promised to bring back a spark that had gone quiet since menopause.
She had mentioned the problem once to her gynecologist, who suggested “a little lubricant” and moved on.
Her best friend’s advice was a wink and a joke about candles.
So here she was, typing “Vigorelle vs HerSolution Gel” and squinting at two ingredient lists that looked almost identical, and not identical at all.
Then she noticed something in the small print. The same company made both.
(Renata is a composite of experiences many women describe, not a real customer.)
The short answer: Vigorelle and HerSolution Gel are both topical arousal products from Leading Edge Health, and both rely on L-arginine plus a mint-derived sensory ingredient. Vigorelle is a water-based cream with peppermint, botanicals and hyaluronic acid that the brand labels condom compatible. HerSolution Gel is a simpler gel with menthol, olive squalene and shea and cocoa butters that feels warm and tingly. Neither is clearly better: the right choice depends on preferred sensation, condom use and skin sensitivity.
Why Most Comparisons of Arousal Gels Miss the Point
Most “best arousal gel for women” lists rank products by star ratings and adjectives. That approach falls apart here, because these two products share a maker, a guarantee and a headline ingredient. The useful differences are in the details: the sensory agent, the base, what else is in the bottle and how each one sits with condoms and sensitive skin.
Skeptics also ask a fair question: if one company sells both, is this just the same product in two boxes? From the ingredient lists, no. They are built on different bases and aimed at slightly different preferences. Whether either one is “better” than a good plain lubricant is a separate question, which I cover in arousal gel vs lubricant.
Vigorelle vs HerSolution Gel: The Ingredient Table
Here are both formulas side by side, grouped by what each ingredient does. Neither brand publishes per-dose amounts, so this compares what is in each product, not how much.
| Role | Vigorelle | HerSolution Gel |
|---|---|---|
| Sensory agent | Peppermint leaf (cooling tingle) | Menthol USP (warm, tingly feel per the brand) |
| Blood-flow ingredient | L-Arginine HCl | L-Arginine |
| Botanicals | Ginkgo, wild yam, damiana, suma | None listed |
| Moisturizers | Hyaluronic acid, aloe vera gel | Aloe vera extract, olive squalene |
| Butters and oils | Olive oil compounds and shea butter (per the brand’s doctor statement) | Shea butter, cocoa butter |
| Vitamins | A, C and E complex | None listed |
| Gel base and pH | Water based, described as pH balanced | Purified water, Carbopol polymer, triethanolamine, citric acid |
| Glycols | Brand says no propylene glycol | Dipropylene glycol |
| Parabens | None, per the brand | None, per the brand |
| Condom compatibility | Labeled condom compatible | Worth confirming with the maker |
What they share
Both contain L-arginine, the amino acid the body uses to make nitric oxide, which relaxes blood vessels. More blood flow to the clitoris is the physical core of arousal, so the logic is sound. The catch is that most supporting research tested oral arginine blends in small studies. How much arginine crosses genital skin from a gel has not been well studied, in either product.
Both also rely on mint chemistry for the immediate sensation. Peppermint leaf contains menthol, and HerSolution Gel lists menthol directly. Menthol activates the nerve receptors that sense cold, which creates tingling and draws attention to the area. That sensation is the most noticeable thing either product does.
Where they differ
Vigorelle adds four botanicals. The evidence for them is modest: ginkgo trials for sexual function, mostly in women on antidepressants, were small and mostly inconclusive; damiana and suma rest largely on traditional use and animal studies; and wild yam cannot be converted into hormones by the human body. I read them as minor contributors at best. Vigorelle also includes hyaluronic acid, a well-established moisture binder, which is a genuine plus for dryness.
HerSolution Gel is the more stripped-down formula. Its texture comes from a Carbopol gel base with olive squalene and two butters, which likely gives it a richer, more cushioned feel. Fewer plant extracts also means fewer potential allergens, which some sensitive women will prefer. My full HerSolution Gel review goes through each of its ingredients.
Texture and Sensation: Cool Mint or Warm Tingle?
Based on each brand’s description and formula, this is the clearest practical difference.
- Vigorelle: described as a “cool tingling” sensation with a minty fresh scent and an edible, non-toxic flavor. Water based, so lighter on the skin, and the brand says it can be reactivated with water or body fluids and washes off easily.
- HerSolution Gel: described as warm and tingly. The butters and squalene suggest a richer, slightly more emollient texture that may linger longer on the skin.
Sensation is personal. Some women find a cooling tingle exciting and clarifying; others find it distracting or chilly and much prefer warmth. Women who already know which they like have most of their answer.
How Each One Is Applied
Vigorelle’s instructions are unusually specific. According to the brand, a small amount goes on the mucous membrane just beneath the clitoris and is rubbed in gently, because the clitoral hood is partially keratinized (a tougher, skin-like surface) and absorbs less. The Vigorelle product page repeats this guidance.
Like most arousal gels, HerSolution Gel is applied in a small amount to the clitoral area shortly before or during intimacy, and its label has the specifics. With both, starting with less than seems necessary is wise, because menthol sensations build over several minutes. Plain water rinses either one off if the feeling becomes too strong.
Condom Compatibility: The Detail That Decides It for Some
For women using latex condoms, this matters more than any herb. Oils and butters can weaken latex, which is why oil-based lubricants are generally not recommended with latex condoms.
Vigorelle’s maker explicitly labels it water based and condom compatible. HerSolution Gel contains shea butter and cocoa butter, and I have not seen the same explicit claim for it, so condom users are wise to confirm compatibility with the maker before relying on it. Vigorelle’s own doctor statement also mentions shea butter in the base, so women with any doubt can ask the company about both. For women who do not use condoms, this point drops away.
Sensitive Skin and Safety Considerations
Genital tissue after menopause is often thinner and more reactive, and both products contain a mint-derived ingredient that can sting. A few points to weigh:
- Fewer ingredients, fewer variables. HerSolution Gel has no botanical extracts, so women with plant allergies (ginkgo, mint family, yam) may tolerate it better.
- Glycols. Vigorelle advertises no propylene glycol. HerSolution Gel contains dipropylene glycol, a related compound that most people tolerate but that occasionally irritates sensitive skin.
- Ginkgo and blood thinners. Vigorelle contains ginkgo. Topical absorption is likely small, but women on anticoagulants may want to mention it to their doctor.
- A patch test either way. A small amount on the inner wrist or thigh for 24 hours before intimate use is sensible with both.
Either product is a poor fit during an active infection, with broken skin, or when intimacy is painful. Pain deserves a medical exam. Women in that situation, or with significant dryness, may find my guide to vaginal dryness during sex more useful than either gel.
Vigorelle or HerSolution: Which Suits Whom
There is no forced winner here. The two products suit different women.
Vigorelle may suit women who
- use latex condoms and want an explicit compatibility claim
- enjoy a cool, minty sensation and a light, water-based feel
- want added moisture from hyaluronic acid
- prefer a formula free of propylene glycol
HerSolution Gel may suit women who
- prefer warmth to coolness
- like a richer, more cushioned texture
- want a shorter ingredient list without botanical extracts
- are also interested in the oral HerSolution supplement, since larger orders include a free month
Women whose main issue is that orgasm has become hard to reach, rather than sensation alone, will get more from the broader approach in my guide to difficulty reaching orgasm after 40. For a closer look at Vigorelle on its own, my Vigorelle review covers every ingredient in detail.
Same Company, Same Guarantee
Both products come from Leading Edge Health, which also makes the oral HerSolution supplement. Both carry the same 67-day money-back guarantee. For Vigorelle, the terms ask customers to try two bottles over 60 days and return the empties within 67 days; shipping is not refunded and refunds are limited to one per customer. Shipping is free in the continental US, and the brand says packaging is discreet. HerSolution Gel orders of three months or more include a free month of the oral HerSolution supplement.
Because the guarantee requires returning bottles, it makes sense to keep the packaging and note the 67-day date when ordering. Prices shift with bundles, so I would rather point to each official site than quote figures that may change.
Realistic Expectations With Either Gel
Both are sensation and comfort products, so whatever they do should be noticeable within minutes of the first few uses, not after weeks. The tingle typically fades within the hour. What neither can do is restore hormones, override medication side effects or create desire that is not there. Some women find that a few more comfortable, more present experiences rebuild confidence, and that can ripple outward. If nothing feels different after several tries, switching to the other product or to a plain lubricant is more sensible than using more.
My Take
Vigorelle is the better-documented choice for condom users and women who like a cool, light feel. HerSolution Gel is the simpler, warmer option for women who want fewer extracts and a richer texture. Women still undecided might start with whichever sensation sounds more appealing, since the shared guarantee makes either a low-risk trial. Full ingredient panels and current offers are on the official Vigorelle site and the official HerSolution Gel site.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Vigorelle and HerSolution Gel made by the same company?
Yes. Both are made by Leading Edge Health and share the same 67-day money-back guarantee.
Which is the best arousal gel for women with sensitive skin?
HerSolution Gel has fewer botanical extracts, while Vigorelle avoids propylene glycol. Both contain mint-derived ingredients, so a patch test matters more than the choice of brand.
Can either gel be used with condoms?
Vigorelle is labeled condom compatible. HerSolution Gel contains shea and cocoa butter, so condom users are wise to confirm compatibility with the maker.
Do these gels contain hormones?
No. Vigorelle contains wild yam, but the body cannot turn it into hormones. HerSolution Gel has no hormone-related ingredients listed.
Is it reasonable to try both?
Some women do, since sensation preference is hard to predict. Using one at a time, with a few days between first tries, makes it easier to tell which one causes any irritation.
Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Anyone who is pregnant, nursing, taking medication or managing a medical condition should speak with a healthcare provider before using a new supplement or intimate product.
Written by Julia Wayne